显示标签为“Asbestos Legislation”的博文。显示所有博文
显示标签为“Asbestos Legislation”的博文。显示所有博文

星期日

Stopping Asbestos is Job for Congress, Administration

Seattle Post-Intelligencer Editorial Board, January 15, 2003
The slow-motion disaster of asbestos that originated in Libby, Mont., may be spreading across the country.
Tens of millions of homes, schools and businesses may contain insulation heavily contaminated by the cancer-causing material. It isn't a cause for panic, but it deserves attention.
The Bush administration, however, has so far ignored the health risks for millions of Americans. In its knowing refusal to face squarely the dangers of asbestos, the administration is in what might be called good company. It joins the ranks of the W.R. Grace & Co., which kept mining asbestos-containing vermiculite in Libby for years with little apparent regard for worker safety, and legions of officials who have failed for decades to protect the public adequately.
The administration should turn itself around on asbestos. It can start by implementing public health and awareness campaigns regarding the asbestos contamination in Libby and in millions of homes. The Zonolite insulation, sold nationally from the '40s through the '90s, used almost exclusively vermiculite from Libby that contained a particularly lethal form of asbestos called tremolite.
Then the administration can do the only truly sensible thing about asbestos: support a bill to ban the use of asbestos. Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., who promises to reintroduce it in this session, sponsored the proposal last year.
First, though, Murray, whose interest in the issue grew out of Post-Intelligencer investigative reports beginning in 1999, is asking for an explanation from the administration of why it dropped plans to declare a public health emergency in Libby, authorizing removal of Zonolite insulation from homes there and providing long-term medical care for people made sick by the asbestos. If it had gone forward, the Environmental Protection Agency action also would have notified homeowners nationally that their insulation could be contaminated.
Former Post-Intelligencer senior national correspondent Andrew Schneider reported in the St. Louis Post-Dispatch in late December that the White House Office of Management and Budget blocked the EPA's plans. That intervention demands explanation of what budget officials considered more important than dealing with a direct threat to human health.
A warning about asbestos-contaminated insulation could save many people from mesothelioma, a disease caused only by asbestos exposure. Mesothelioma, which develops years after exposure, kills 2,000 people a year.
The larger question, however, is why the nation has never banned asbestos. By the middle of last year, at least 20 countries had banned asbestos. A ban will go into effect in 2005 across the European Union. During the Reagan administration and the first Bush administration, the EPA had the good sense to try to ban asbestos. But it lost a court case.
Murray's bill contains a wealth of sensible proposals, including a process for exemptions if no substitute for asbestos is available. Asbestos is used most often now in brakes, gaskets and roofing materials. Murray's bill also would advance mesothelioma research and treatment.
The conventional wisdom is that environmental protection will receive little positive attention in the new Congress with Republican control of both houses. But the assessment may be simplistic. A Murray spokesman compares the issue to her pipeline safety legislation, which passed last year with broad bipartisan support and with President Bush's signature.
Murray is seeking Republican co-sponsors on the asbestos bill. Asbestos shouldn't be a partisan issue -- it's about public safety.

Asbestos Death Toll: 10,000 Americans a Year - and Rising

Study Details Fatalities in Each U.S. County - Warns of Congressional Plan to Deny Victims Help
WASHINGTON, March 4 - As the U.S. Senate considers a bill to protect companies from lawsuits brought by hundreds of thousands of Americans harmed by asbestos, the first-ever analysis of federal mortality records finds that 10,000 Americans die each year from asbestos exposure, and projects that up to ten times that many will die in the next decade.
More Americans die each year from cancers and other illnesses caused by asbestos than from fires and drowning combined, according to the study released today by the EWG Action Fund. Since 1979, more than 43,000 Americans have died from asbestos-related diseases, and the study details for the first time the death toll in each state and county nationwide. (The study is available at www.ewg.org.)
Although many Americans believe that asbestos has already been banned and its victims have been compensated by the courts, the EWG Action Fund study found that the conventional wisdom about this deadly material is almost completely wrong. Says Action Fund researcher Richard Wiles, lead author: "We took a new look at an old subject and found that asbestos is not an economic issue but a public health crisis - one that has yet to reach its peak."
The study reports that 30 million pounds of asbestos are used in the U.S. each year, lists dozens of widely-used consumer products that still contain it, and says more than one million workers are exposed every year. For the first time, EWG Action Fund's interactive website shows Americans how close they live to a site where asbestos was shipped or processed. The study lists sites nationwide where asbestos cleanup is most critical and finds that more than 100,000 people live within half a mile of a site.
The website goes behind doors at asbestos companies, making public decades of secret documents proving that the corporations knew asbestos was deadly but continued to poison their workers and the public for the sake of profits. EWG Action Fund researchers found that less than two per cent of workers exposed to asbestos have asked for help paying medical bills, and that companies who claim to have been driven bankrupt by asbestos suits tell shareholders their bottom lines have not suffered.
The Senate is currently considering a proposal to set up a special fund the bill's proponents claim will take care of all asbestos victims once and for all. But because asbestos-related diseases take up to 50 years to show up, even if everyone who is sick today was helped, the fund would deny justice to hundreds of thousands who have yet to become ill. EWG Action Fund researchers recommend that the federal government ban asbestos immediately and look for a policy solution that will care for all victims - now and in the future.

Two doctors see asbestos legislation in very different lights; Those ill would get some compensation, but would give up right to sue

The Associated Press, April 19, 2004
WASHINGTON - Bret Williams isn't used to being on the business end of a stethoscope. The 52-year-old doctor's place was on the other side, listening to the heartbeats of the rural North Carolinians who were once his patients.
Not any more, not since he learned last year that he has a crippling disease himself: malignant mesothelioma caused by asbestos exposure from childhood, summer jobs and home repairs.
Nonetheless, the Hillsborough, N.C., internist is fighting a plan in Congress that would provide him and thousands of other Americans compensation from asbestos companies but bar them from suing.
The Senate began debate Monday on setting up a $114 billion trust fund financed by businesses and insurance companies to speed money to people with asbestos-related diseases. In exchange, victims could not take asbestos makers to court.
Bill opponents
"The victims are being portrayed as corporations who are losing money as a result of the courts," Williams said during a recent Washington visit to lobby against the bill. "But the real victims are patients like me.
"I'd like to remind Bill Frist that he and I both think that the most important thing is to first do no harm to our patients. The legislation that is pending would serve only to shield corporations from liability for poisoning me and people like me. This bill would not help patients; it would only cause harm."
Despite a new push by Senate Republicans, asbestos sufferers like Williams allied with Democrats, lawyers and union advocates are likely to again block enactment by the closely divided Senate.
Asbestos is a fibrous mineral commonly used until the mid-1970s for insulation and fireproofing. When inhaled, its tiny fibers can cause cancer and other ailments. The diseases often take decades to develop.
Senate push
Most senators agree that something needs to be done for the hundreds of thousands of Americans sickened through high levels of asbestos exposure over long periods of time. Most also agree that some type of government-monitored fund would be best.
"Rest assured, without congressional action, the problem is not going away. In 2003 alone, a record 100,000 asbestos claims were filed," said Senate Judiciary Committee Chairman Orrin Hatch, R-Utah. He conceded, however, that his effort with Frist is unlikely to succeed this year.
Their proposed fund would have the ability to pay claimants quickly by demanding payments from corporate and insurance industry participants within six months of the bill's enactment.
The sickest people also would get priority if they can prove they have mesothelioma or can get a doctor to testify they are terminally ill from an asbestos-related illness and have a life expectancy of less than one year.
Democrats say the bill doesn't provide enough money for victims in exchange for forever ending their rights to sue the companies they think sickened them.
Senate Minority Leader Tom Daschle, D-S.D., said the bill includes a provision "that says victims with asbestos-related lung cancer and 15 weighted years of asbestos exposure would receive only $25,000 in compensation."
"I literally cannot imagine how anybody could support legislation that says that is all they are entitled to," Daschle said.
Election politics?
Conservatives counter that Democrats wouldn't approve anything they proposed in an election year when they look to unions and trial lawyers for support.
"Some say - I think somewhat cynically - many of our colleagues on the other side are not going to vote for this bill because ... two of their major constituencies are against the bill," said Hatch.
Democrats reply that Republicans are bringing up the bill only to slap at trial lawyers - who contribute largely to the Democratic Party - and please their supporters in the business and insurance industries, which rank ending asbestos lawsuits as one of their top priorities.
"As the majority leader knows from conversations I have had with him, it is unlikely this legislation will be able to move," Daschle said. "One would think that perhaps this is just another effort politically that will not have any result legislatively."
Some Republicans heavily invested in finding an asbestos solution also questioned Frist's decision to bring the bill up in April.
"I declined to join with Sen. Frist and Sen. Hatch in their substitute bill because I think it is the better practice to try to work through these problems," said Sen. Arlen Specter, R-Pa.
Williams, for his part, calls himself lucky because most people stricken with asbestos-related diseases don't have access to the care he has. "They're just sent home to die," he said.

Senate's Daschle Says Still Time for Asbestos Deal

Reuters, June 15, 2004, Susan Cornwell
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - There is still time for Congress to pass legislation on asbestos reform this year, the Senate Democratic leader said on Tuesday, striking an upbeat note on an effort that appeared to have stalled last month.
Sen. Tom Daschle acknowledged that progress might be taking place "at a snail's pace," but said he and Senate Republican Leader Bill Frist were still seeking a bipartisan consensus on setting up a national fund to pay asbestos victims' claims.
"We aren't going to give up until its absolutely clear that there is no possibility of achieving agreement," Daschle, a South Dakota Democrat, told reporters outside the Senate.
"We still have time, and if it's a bipartisan agreement that Senator Frist and I feel comfortable proposing to our caucus, I think we can pass it in a reasonable period of time and get it over to the House (of Representatives)." Daschle said.
"And if they could see fit to do the same we could still get it on the president's desk this year, and that's my hope," Daschle added. He was responding to a question about prospects for a Senate deal on asbestos.
Several senators have been working for more than a year on legislation setting up an asbestos compensation fund, which would be financed by asbestos litigation defendants and insurers.
But organized labor representatives have said business offers have fallen short of the money needed to pay thousands of asbestos claims stretching into the future.
Daschle and Frist said last month they would keep open the possibility of an agreement on an asbestos fund after an effort by a senior appeals court judge to mediate among asbestos companies, insurers and labor representatives failed.
But the effort is competing with numerous other issues for ever-scarcer Senate time in an election year.
A spokeswoman for Frist, a Tennessee Republican, said staff-level discussions on asbestos were continuing.
"Senator Frist also feels strongly that we should continue working on a deal, and hopefully, for the good of the American people, and for the good of those suffering with asbestos, we can come to an agreement so they can compensated," spokeswoman Amy Call said.
Asbestos was widely used for fireproofing and insulation until the 1970s. Scientists say inhaled fibers are linked to cancer and other diseases.
Companies have paid an estimated $70 billion on some 730,000 asbestos personal injury claims, making it the most expensive type of litigation in U.S. history, according to the RAND Institute for Civil Justice.
Many companies facing asbestos claims have filed for bankruptcy; among those that have done so in recent years are building materials company Owens Corning and auto parts

Proposed Asbestos Fund Divides Victims

Proposed Asbestos Fund Divides VictimsCompensation Plan Bypasses Courts
Washington Post, April 20, 2004, Albert B. Crenshaw
For much of the past month, Washington television and radio airwaves have been filled with advertisements featuring the images or voices of victims of asbestos-related illnesses.
In some, victims implore viewers or listeners to help them head off a congressional attempt to deny them their day in court so they can sue the companies they hold responsible for their plight. In others, people implore viewers and listeners to urge Congress to come to their assistance because they say the courts are too clogged to be of any use.
The focus of these ads is a bill on the Senate floor this week that would create a nationwide compensation fund to pay victims' medical bills and other damages -- while cutting their lawyers out of the payoff.
The lawyers, the victims they represent and other interests argue that the bill, crafted by Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist (R-Tenn.) and Judiciary Committee Chairman Orrin G. Hatch (R-Utah), is hopelessly inadequate. With a potential payout of $114 billion, they regard the bill as a bailout for asbestos producers and their insurers, and "an outrageous attack on the rights of asbestos victims, leaving them without the help they need while shutting them out of the legal system," said Jeff Blum, executive director of USAction, an advocacy group on the lawyers' side.
Blum's group organized a press conference on Capitol Hill yesterday featuring a group of victims and widows of victims of mesothelioma, a particularly aggressive form of cancer that is almost always fatal and is tied to asbestos exposure. They included Sue Vento, widow of Rep. Bruce Vento (D-Minn.), a 12-term member of Congress who died of the disease in 2000. The group urged the Senate to defeat the bill.
Julie Rochman, senior vice president of public affairs for the American Insurance Association, said her side would have a group of victims here today to meet with members on Capitol Hill.
Victims "should be heard," she said. "We agree . . . they need quick, fair compensation."
She said the present system, in which claims go through the courts, is not doing a good job of getting compensation to those who really need it.
The bill as introduced would pay as much as $124 billion (counting $10 billion in contingency provisions), and if that turns out not to be enough, victims who cannot get payment from the trust can return to the courts, Rochman said. "There is not a single victim who would be left holding the bag," she said.
The bill would establish medical criteria for payment, "and that's promising," she said.
Other issues, such as how to deal with pending claims, remain unresolved. Opponents say the bill would wipe out judgments victims have already won; proponents say that isn't so. "Nobody is going to argue a widow who has a final judgment . . . should be set back at the start of the claims process," Rochman said, but insurers oppose mass "inventory claims . . . where there aren't even real people attached to the claims."
Senate aides said the fate of the measure is uncertain. Unless the two sides can resolve their differences, the bill's backers are unlikely to muster enough support to shut off debate, and the bill would probably be set aside at least for the time being, the aides said.
One area about which both sides agree is the seriousness of the situation. Asbestos was widely used in American industry for much of the 20th century, and even now has not been completely banned. It was employed in fireproofing, insulation, automobile parts such as brake shoes and other applications where resistance to heat was important. Asbestos consists of tiny silicate mineral fibers that, when inhaled, cause a variety of ailments as well as mesothelioma.
Companies that produced asbestos are accused of concealing the mineral's danger long after they knew of it. Lawsuits by victims have pushed more than 70 companies into bankruptcy, and the number of claims continues to grow.
A study by the Environmental Working Group, an organization opposing the bill, figures that 10,000 people are dying every year from asbestos-related illnesses, and 100,000 are developing nonfatal ailments.

U.S. Asbestos Fund Would Quickly go Broke -- Study

Reuters - September 19, 2005
WASHINGTON, Sept 19 (Reuters) - A $140 billion asbestos compensation fund being considered in the U.S. Senate would be swamped by more than double that amount in claims and go broke within three years, according to a study released on Monday. The proposed fund would face claims of between $301 billion and $561 billion, as people with lung and other cancers, who historically had not been compensated by asbestos lawsuits, file for their new entitlements, the study said.
The analysis was done by Bates White, a Washington D.C. economic consulting firm, at the request of the American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), an association of conservative state lawmakers.
Asbestos fibers have been used in building materials, auto parts and other products for decades, but are linked to cancer and other diseases. Hundreds of thousands of injury claims have pushed many companies into bankruptcy.
Pennsylvania Republican Sen. Arlen Specter and Vermont Democrat Sen. Patrick Leahy are sponsoring a bill to take asbestos injury claims out of the courts and pay them from a fund financed by asbestos defendant companies and insurers.
The Bates White estimate of the fund's payouts was much larger than an estimate last month by the nonpartisan Congressional Budget Office. The CBO said the proposed fund would have to pay out between $120 billion and $150 billion in claims to people who were sickened by asbestos.
The new analysis said it differed with the CBO because the CBO had assumed that people with lung and other cancers would file claims to the new fund at the same rate that they had filed asbestos claims in court.
But the fund would create a new entitlement for people who historically were not compensated in court, the study said. Few individuals with these cancers have had viable claims in court, because asbestos was only one of the risk factors that may have caused their conditions, it said.
"In order for CBO to be correct, more than 85 percent of qualifying individuals with lung and other cancers would have to decide not to collect their (average) $500,000 entitlement" from the fund, the study said.
The American Legislative Exchange Council prefers state-level action to curb asbestos claims, said its director of legislation and policy, Sandy Liddy Bourne, in a statement accompanying the study.
Lawmakers in four states -- Ohio, Texas, Florida and Georgia -- have enacted laws establishing medical criteria that claimants must meet in order to bring asbestos injury lawsuits.
The asbestos fund bill was approved by the Senate Judiciary Committee in May. But with doubts about how much support it has in either party, it has not been brought to the Senate floor. Specter says he hopes it will come to the floor early in October

Let History Be a Lesson

Let History Be a Lesson - an Asbestos Trust Fund Won't Work
by Ethan Early - January 6, 2006
Senator Arlen Specter (R) of Pennsylvania has proposed a $140 billion trust fund solution to asbestos litigation, which may voted on the floor of the United States Senate in January or February of 2006. While Senator Specter's motives may be noble, his solution only creates more problems than currently exist, and his solution is fatally flawed. Senator Specter's desire to pass this asbestos legislation has trumped his rationality on the topic. Thousands upon thousands of claimants will be denied compensation they deserve, many businesses will be hurt or destroyed, and taxpayers may be forced to pick up the tab as the trust fund approach crumbles under the weight of its numerous and significant problems.
Recently, in light of the asbestos trust fund approach, the United States Government Accountability Office ("GAO") reviewed four federal compensation programs designed to compensate individuals injured due to exposure to harmful substances- black lung, vaccine injury, radiation exposure, energy employees occupational illness- and determined the following:
the compensation programs have seen an expanded federal role and higher costs over time;
all four programs have been expanded to provide additional categories of claimants, cover more medical conditions, or provide additional benefits;
some programs have been extended longer than planned;
there have been far more claims than estimated for each program;
there have been significant delays in completing claims for victims; and
it took at least 2 years for all four programs to become fully operational.
Extrapolating the GAO information, it is clear that the asbestos trust fund won't work because it already exhibits many of the flaws which have befallen these previous federal compensation schemes, even assuming that a new federal bureaucracy runs smoothly! For example:
a study places the cost to adequately cover the trust fund as high as $561 billion;
the Congressional Budget Office acknowledges that resources may be insufficient to pay all claims and the trust fund will have to borrow billions of dollars over the first ten years to pay qualified claims;
it is predicted that many more claimants will file for benefits because it is seemingly easier than engaging in litigation; and
the trust fund will be mired in litigation over its constitutionality from its very first day of enactment, thereby delaying its start-up.
Ultimately, the GAO warning that policymakers must consider the costs of establishing a federal compensation program in times of serious federal deficits, coupled with valid concerns by claimants, insurers, and many business, set forth that this asbestos trust fund is fatally flawed and doomed to fail, thereby leaving claimants, many businesses and federal tax payers either out in the cold or on the hook.

星期四

Asbestos Legislation

This page contains information about the asbestos legislation currently being proposed in the Senate.
Let History Be a Lesson - an Asbestos Trust Fund Won't Work
By Ethan Early - January 06, 2006
A look at four federal compensation programs designed to compensate individuals injured due to exposure to harmful substances as they relate to the proposed Asbestos Trust Fund.
U.S. Asbestos Fund Would Quickly go Broke -- Study
A $140 billion asbestos compensation fund being considered in the U.S. Senate would be swamped by more than double that amount in claims and go broke within three years, according to a study released on Monday...
Reuters - September 19, 2005
Senate's Daschle Says Still Time for Asbestos Deal
There is still time for Congress to pass legislation on asbestos reform this year, the Senate Democratic leader said on Tuesday, striking an upbeat note on an effort that appeared to have stalled last month.
Reuters, Susan Crowell, June 15, 2004
Asbestos legislation Falls Apart in the Senate
Once-promising legislation to compensate asbestos victims while shielding companies from crippling jury awards collapsed yesterday in the Senate amid charges of election-year gamesmanship. The $124 billion bill, which was written by Senate Republicans with comment from the asbestos and insurance industries, fell far short of the 60 votes needed to end the debate. The vote was 50-47.
Charles Pope, Seattle Post-Intelligencer, April 23, 2004
Proposed Asbestos Fund Divides Victims
For much of the past month, Washington television and radio airwaves have been filled with advertisements featuring the images or voices of victims of asbestos-related illnesses.
Washington Post, Albert B. Crenshaw, April 20, 2004
Two Doctors see Asbestos Legislation in very Different Lights
Bret Williams isn't used to being on the business end of a stethoscope. The 52-year-old doctor's place was on the other side, listening to the heartbeats of the rural North Carolinians who were once his patients. Not any more, not since he learned last year that he has a crippling disease himself: malignant mesothelioma caused by asbestos exposure from childhood, summer jobs and home repairs.
The Associated Press, April 19, 2004
Asbestos Death Toll: 10,000 Americans a Year - and Rising
Asbestos deaths in the United States have skyrocketed since the late 1960s and will probably keep on climbing through the next decade because of long-ago exposure to the material, once widely used for insulation and fireproofing, the government said Thursday.
EWG Action Fund, Public Affairs Dept., March 4, 2004
Stopping asbestos is job for Congress, Administration
The slow-motion disaster of asbestos that originated in Libby, Mont., may be spreading across the country. Tens of millions of homes, schools and businesses may contain insulation heavily contaminated by the cancer-causing material. It isn't a cause for panic, but it deserves attention.
Seattle Post-Intelligencer Editorial Board, January 15, 2003
Fairness in Asbestos Injury Resolution Act
Actual draft of Fairness in Asbestos Injury Resolution Act of 2004
108th Congress, 2nd Session